Excerpt from
"Remote Control" By
Brendan I Koerner Mother Jones October 1, 2001
With its innocent-sounding name and barely
concealed pro-industry agenda, the Location Privacy Association is a
classic example of an "Astroturf" group, Beltway slang for
pseudo-grassroots organizations. Though telecom issues have yet to
generate much public debate, companies are sponsoring a variety of
groups to suggest that Americans are clamoring for deregulation. One
of the most visible is the Alliance for Public Technology, whose board
members are frequently quoted in the media as crusaders for the public
interest, especially for rural and minority consumers. According to
the group's 1989 application for nonprofit status, its mission is to
"educate the general public about new technology" and "bridge the gap
between technology providers and special-need consumers."
Other filings, however, reveal that the
alliance operates out of the offices of Issue Dynamics, a consulting
firm often hired by the Bells; in 1999, the group paid Issue Dynamics
$140,000 in "management fees." On its Web site the alliance lists four
corporate sponsors—AOL Time Warner, BellSouth, SBC, and the U.S.
Telecom Association-and it regularly provides press statements and
congressional testimony in support of its backers' goals. When a
broadband deregulation bill co-sponsored by Rep. W.J. "Billy" Tauzin
(R-La.) and Rep. John Dingell (D-Mich.) came under fire from consumer
advocates, alliance representative Don Vial emerged to praise the
measure before the House Commerce Committee: "There can never be
enough broadband to serve the increasing needs of our
technology-driven economy and society."
To mobilize, or at least imply, real
public support, corporations have used massive ad campaigns, often
targeted at the Washington media market. The Tauzin-Dingell bill, for
example, has spurred a flood of commercials from Keep America
Connected, a Bell-funded group that says it represents “older
Americans, people with disabilities, rural and inner-city residents,
people of color, low-income citizens, labor and local telephone
companies." The organization lists a bevy of affiliates, including the
American Beekeeping Federation, the Delta Waterfowl Foundation—and the
Alliance for Public Technology. Another Bell lobbying group, Connect
USA, has been saturating the D.C. airwaves with ads assuring viewers
that Tauzin-Dingell "guarantees high-speed access to inner cities and
small towns, making sure that no one is left behind."